Girls, which are you more attracted to?

Would you be more attracted to a clean-cut, goody-goody-looking guy that has kind of a high-pitched voice that wears polo shirts and khaki pants and other attire that looks like a 40 year old dad would wear OR a guy that has scruffy cheeks, is more rugged, has a deep voice, wears clothes that a soccer dad wouldn't be caught dead in, etc.? I'm just wondering because I see a lot of the first type of guy, and I just think, HOW could anybody be sexually attracted to you EVER? I just want to know if there are any girls/women out there that prefer the first type? I personally like guys that don't look like they need to be patted on the head and given a cookie or dress like a groany, old man when they're 20.